01Overview & Snapshot
This brief anchors on an assumed purchase price of $1,150,000. That sits ~18% above the $977,492 AVM and ~22% above the cleanest comparable on record — 20 Kianga Parade, an identical 3·2·2 on the same 558 m² lot size and the same street, sold $939,000 in March 2026 (19 Sunset Boulevard, 3·2·2, made $900,000 in October 2025). Paying $1.15M requires premium attributes the records can't see — outlook, position, condition — or it's above the market. Budget for a valuation shortfall at that price and order an upfront val where the lender allows. Growth since the May 2019 purchase at $535,000 implies ~+9% p.a. to the AVM.
02Five-Year Trajectory — Narooma Houses (Proxy Market)
Kianga records too few sales for its own suburb-level series, so adjoining Narooma (same 2546 postcode, ~3 km south) is used as the proxy market throughout sections 02–03. The shape tells the story: a sharp COVID-era boom (Jun 2020 → mid-2022, roughly +72%), a peak-to-trough correction of about 15% into a cycle low around mid-2025, then a modest recovery over the last 12 months. Rent has climbed steadily throughout — the more reliable performer.
| Period (Jun) | Typical Price | Median Rent /wk | Phase |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | $596,263 | — | Pre-boom |
| 2021 | $823,747 | $377 | Boom |
| 2022 | $1,027,114 | $441 | Near peak |
| 2023 | $960,942 | $454 | Correcting |
| 2024 | $902,146 | $467 | Correcting |
| 2025 | $872,708 | $487 | Cycle low |
| 2026 | $893,184 | $500 | Recovering |
03Growth & Yield (Narooma Proxy)
| Horizon | Price CAGR | Rent CAGR |
|---|---|---|
| 1 year | +2.35% | +2.67% |
| 3 year | −2.41% | +3.27% |
| 5 year | +1.63% | +5.81% |
| 10 year | +7.21% | +7.93% |
Narooma-house growth rates, applied to Kianga as proxy. The subject's own history runs ahead of the suburb: $535k (May 2019) → ~$940–980k today is roughly +9% p.a. through the same boom–bust–recovery cycle.
The property has never been on the rental record — consistent with Kianga's owner-occupier / holiday-house profile. Long-term-lease yields here are thin (~2.8% gross); the income case, if any, is short-stay (section 06).
04Five-Year Price Projection
Projected values from the $1,150,000 assumed purchase price. Scenarios are model-based extrapolations of Narooma-proxy history — not forecasts or valuations.
The pure 5-year CAGR is anchored to the 2022 peak and understates likely forward growth. With the proxy market having bottomed around mid-2025 and turned upward (+2.35% over the last year), a central case of roughly $1.35M–$1.4M over five years is the most defensible read from a $1.15M entry — though note the entry itself is above current sold evidence (section 01) — and waterside Kianga stock has historically run ahead of the Narooma blend.
05Comparable Sales
Houses (3+ bed) sold within ~5 km over the last nine months (property records, priced sales only). Sold evidence is the strongest test of the $977,492 AVM.
| Address | Bd·Ba·Car | Land | Sold | Sold price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 68 Williamson Drive, Nth Narooma | 4 · 3 · 3 | 2,013 m² | 27 Oct 25 | $1,560,000 |
| 20 Dawn Parade, Kianga | 5 · 3 · 2 | 1,140 m² | 02 Dec 25 | $1,345,000 |
| 7 Beachview Close, Nth Narooma | 4 · 3 · 2 | 993 m² | 12 Dec 25 | $1,255,000 |
| 20 Kianga Parade, Kianga | 3 · 2 · 2 | 558 m² | 13 Mar 26 | $939,000 |
| 19 Sunset Boulevard, Kianga | 3 · 2 · 2 | 600 m² | 21 Oct 25 | $900,000 |
| 55 Warbler Crescent, Nth Narooma | 3 · 2 · 4 | 737 m² | 19 Dec 25 | $880,000 |
| 33 Warbler Crescent, Nth Narooma | 3 · 2 · 2 | 991 m² | 03 Nov 25 | $870,000 |
| 28 Sunset Boulevard, Kianga | 4 · 2 · 2 | 556 m² | 17 Oct 25 | $745,000 |
| 2 Tower Lane, Nth Narooma | 4 · 2 · 2 | 945 m² | 21 Oct 25 | $735,000 |
20 Kianga Parade is a near-perfect comparable — same street, identical 3·2·2 configuration and 558 m² lot — at $939,000 in March 2026. The local 3-bed band runs $870k–$939k, bracketing just under the $977,492 AVM; larger waterside stock (Dawn Parade, Beachview, Williamson) clears $1.25M–$1.56M. Five further nearby sales (5 Woodbury Rd, 46 Hillcrest Ave, 16 Kianga Pde, 18 Lakeside Dr, 21 Dawn Pde) settled recently with prices not yet disclosed — worth re-checking before an offer.
Narooma houses (proxy) took an average of ~62 days to sell over the last six months, down sharply from 115–178 days through early-mid 2025, with inventory around 5.6 months. The 2546 market is tightening, but not hot — well-priced 3-bed stock near the water is transacting.
06Short-Stay (Airbnb) Revenue Scenario
Modelled from AirROI data (trailing 12 months, Jun 2025 – May 2026, refreshed 2 July 2026 — all figures AUD) and comparable 3-bedroom listings. AirROI's address-level estimate for a 3-bed / 2-bath / 6-guest home at this location is ~$69,400 gross a year at a $432 ADR and 45% occupancy (p25 ~$34k · p75 ~$78k · p90 ~$106k) — notably stronger than an equivalent Narooma in-town home, reflecting Kianga's beachside strip. Demand peaks in January and is softest in May, with an average stay of ~4.6 nights.
| Listing | Revenue (TTM) | Occupancy | ADR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buena Vista 62 (3BR, sleeps 8) | $112,585 | 70.1% | $426 |
| Riverview Beach House (3BR) | $93,557 | 94.0% | $252 |
| Spectacular Ocean Views (3BR) | $81,560 | 47.4% | $403 |
| Yabbarra Sands, Kianga (3BR) | $75,596 | 54.0% | $320 |
| 4 Dawn Parade, Kianga (3BR) | $67,238 | 34.0% | $453 |
Kianga itself hosts several active short-stay 3-beds — Yabbarra Sands ($75.6k) and 4 Dawn Parade ($67.2k) sit within a few hundred metres of the subject, both clearing the AirROI central estimate.
| Scenario | ADR | Occ. | Gross revenue | Est. net (ex-mortgage) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conservative / lightly run (p25) | $250 | ~31% | ~$34,000 | ~$18–20k |
| Moderate / well-managed (central) | $432 | ~45% | ~$69,000 | ~$36–42k |
| Strong / top-tier operator (p75) | $470 | ~57% | ~$78,000 | ~$41–47k |
Net figures assume short-stay operating costs of ~40–48% of gross — materially heavier than a long-term lease. About 37% of local listings are professionally managed (15–20% management fee); cleaning fees average ~$345 per turnover (median $378); add platform fees, higher utilities/wifi, short-stay insurance, linen/consumables and faster wear. A top-decile operator (p90) can gross ~$106,000 at 69%+ occupancy. A one-off furnishing fit-out of ~$25–40k for a 3-bed is not included above.
07Rates, Revenue & Seasonality
Market-wide AirROI benchmarks for all listings in the Narooma market, which covers Kianga (TTM Jun 2025 – May 2026, AUD). Headline averages: $377 ADR, 33.9% occupancy, $127 RevPAR; average booking lead time ~79 days. Listings that earned revenue averaged ~$34,000 for the year (median ~$27,600); across all 183 tracked listings (including owner-blocked homes) the average was ~$21,200. Performance splits widely by tier and by season.
Market-average ADR is $377; a well-run 3-bedroom targets the upper tiers — the market's top 3-bed comps achieved $721 and $768 a night. The green bar marks the Top-25% band ($456), the realistic target for a quality-managed listing.
Revenue swings hard with the calendar. The single strongest month (January) reaches ~$6,401 at 51% occupancy; the weakest (May) drops to ~$2,490 at 22%. These are market-wide averages across all listings — an actively-managed 3-bed runs materially higher in peak, around ~69% occupancy in January at a 45% annual average (modelled in the section 09 calculator). Building a cash buffer from the peak months to carry the off-season is essential.
| Tier | ADR | Occupancy | Monthly rev. | ~Annual rev. | RevPAR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bottom 25% | $262 | 15% | $1,567 | ~$18,800 | $52 |
| Median | $351 | 30% | $3,122 | ~$37,500 | $103 |
| Top 25% | $456 | 48% | $5,305 | ~$63,700 | $175 |
| Top 10% | $601 | 69% | $8,125 | ~$97,500 | $268 |
The spread between top and bottom performers is enormous — a ~5× revenue gap driven by presentation, pricing strategy and availability. RevPAR (rate × realised occupancy) is the cleanest single efficiency measure: the market median is $103, top-quartile is $175+. (Tier annual figures compound monthly percentiles, so treat them as indicative bands, not per-listing forecasts.)
08Supply, Hosts & Market
Kianga sits inside AirROI's Narooma short-stay market — a boutique market of ~113 currently active listings (183 tracked over the year, ~104 active in any given month), ~97% entire homes, with supply up roughly 8% year-on-year (103 → 111 monthly actives). By property type it skews to apartments/units (48%) with houses at ~33% plus cottages, cabins and guesthouses; by size, 2-bed (41%) and 3-bed (27%) dominate, with 41% offering 3+ bedrooms and 14% at 4+ bedrooms. About 37% of listings are professionally managed.
| Listing | Beds | Revenue | Occ. | ADR |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Seamist Cottage | 4 | $143,984 | 58.9% | $525 |
| 12 Bluewater Drive | 4 | $119,777 | 36.4% | $734 |
| Luxury Apartment w/ views | 3 | $107,440 | 34.5% | $721 |
| Farm Stay Cottage (Tilba) | 2 | $97,977 | 94.5% | $271 |
| 19 Lakeview Drive | 5 | $87,600 | 48.2% | $394 |
| Wharf Apartment Unit 11 | 3 | $81,276 | 25.5% | $768 |
The top listings show two routes to strong revenue: high ADR with moderate occupancy (12 Bluewater at $734 × 36%), or lower ADR with very high occupancy (Farm Stay Cottage at $271 × 95%). Both clear ~$98k+, and the best 3-beds are close behind — Buena Vista 62 ($112.6k) and the Luxury Apartment ($107.4k).
| Host / Manager | Listings | Gross revenue | Avg rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whale Coast (manager) | 71 | $1,993,643 | 4.45 |
| Robert | 3 | $162,348 | 4.95 |
| John | 2 | $148,959 | 4.81 |
| Sally | 1 | $107,440 | 4.88 |
| Kylie | 1 | $97,977 | 4.98 |
| LJ Hooker (manager) | 1 | $56,566 | 3.67 |
One operator — Whale Coast — dominates, running 71 of the 183 tracked listings at a $413 ADR but only ~15% occupancy. The remainder is a long tail of individual owner-hosts, several rating 4.9+ with far stronger occupancy. A new entrant competes mainly on presentation and pricing against a single professional incumbent whose portfolio under-fills.
| Market | Listings | Avg monthly rev. | ADR | Occupancy |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Narooma | 113 | ~$3,843* | $377 | 34% |
| Callala Beach | 169 | $6,072 | $804 | 36% |
| Hyams Beach | 114 | $5,507 | $687 | 34% |
| Huskisson | 265 | $5,281 | $541 | 40% |
| Vincentia | 486 | $4,694 | $586 | 37% |
| Currarong | 109 | $4,231 | $607 | 37% |
*Average revenue per active listing-month. Narooma sits below the Jervis Bay / Shoalhaven markets (the Shoalhaven LGA tracks ~1,238 listings in total) — and the gap is now clearly rate, not just availability: occupancy is broadly in line with the neighbours, but Narooma's $377 ADR is 30–55% below Huskisson, Vincentia, Hyams Beach and Callala Beach. Owner-blocked holiday homes still drag the blended average further. An actively-let 3-bed at Kianga (modelled at ~$69k in section 06) would sit well above the blended market average.
09Airbnb Revenue Calculator
Interactive model — adjust occupancy and nightly rate to test returns for this property. Benchmarks come from AirROI's address-level estimate for a 3-bedroom at 57 Kianga Parade (refreshed 2 July 2026, AUD). Seasonality follows AirROI's monthly revenue distribution for this address — January runs ≈ 69% at the default 45% annual average. The loan defaults to 100% borrowing against the $1,150,000 assumed purchase price (no down payment) at 6.5% p.a. over 30 years; zero the loan amount for a cash-purchase view. The Target Revenue card works backwards from an acceptable monthly shortfall (default $1,000/mo out-of-pocket) to the Airbnb revenue the property must earn.
Property
Variables
AirROI's estimate for a well-run 3-bed at this address is 45% occupancy and a $432 ADR. Adjust both to match this property's positioning.
Seasonality
Avg $5.3kExpenses
Itemised operating costs — adjust to real quotes/bills. Management, platform and cleaning scale with bookings; the rest are fixed holding costs. Cleaning assumes ~4.6-night average stays (AirROI), with most of the fee recharged to guests. Defaults are regional-NSW estimates, not quotes.
Total: $31,965/yr ($2,664/mo) ≈ 45% of gross.
Financials
Target Revenue — Acceptable Monthly Shortfall
Set the maximum out-of-pocket contribution you're comfortable with each month (after operating expenses and the loan repayment). The model works backwards to the Airbnb revenue the property must earn — and what that requires at the current rate and occupancy settings.
Benchmark check: Above the 90th-percentile revenue ($106,102/yr) — unrealistic for this market; increase the shortfall allowance or reduce the loan.
Comparable Short-Stay Properties
AirROI comparable-set revenue for similar 3-bed listings (TTM, AUD, refreshed 2 July 2026).
| Listing | Revenue | ADR | Occ | Bd | Ba | Guests |
|---|
Return on Investment
The loan repayment, annual profit and cash-on-cash now update live from the loan inputs (principal & interest). The model remains indicative — for a finance decision use section 06's net figures and the credit team's serviceability assessment; short-stay income is typically discounted or excluded for servicing.
10Short-Stay vs Long-Term & Regulation
| Strategy | Gross p.a. | Est. net p.a. | Gross yield on $1.15M | Effort / risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long-term lease (~$520/wk) | ~$27,000 | ~$21,000 | 2.3% | Low-touch, stable |
| Short-stay — conservative | ~$34,000 | ~$18–20k | 3.0% | High-touch, seasonal |
| Short-stay — moderate | ~$69,000 | ~$36–42k | 6.0% | High-touch, seasonal |
| Short-stay — strong operator | ~$78,000 | ~$41–47k | 6.8% | Top-quartile execution |
The read: the strategy gap is wider here than in-town Narooma. Long-term leasing is weak (~2.8% gross, ~$21k net) while the short-stay central case nets ~$36–42k — roughly $15–20k a year ahead of a lease — because Kianga's beachside strip commands a $432 estimated ADR. The nearest comparable listings (Yabbarra Sands, 4 Dawn Parade) already operate at or above the central case. A lightly-run listing still underperforms; the property only makes income sense actively managed.
Kianga sits in Eurobodalla Shire, which chose not to adopt the optional 180-day cap on non-hosted short-term rental accommodation. Non-hosted STRA can therefore operate up to 365 days a year. Obligations still apply: registration on the NSW STRA Register ($65 initial / $25 annual renewal) with the STRA Property ID displayed on every listing, compliance with the NSW fire safety standard, and the mandatory code of conduct. The NSW STRA framework is under review, so caps could tighten in future — a watch-item, not a current constraint.
11Data Confidence & Watch-Points
- Kianga transacts too few houses for suburb-level statistics — sections 02–04 use adjoining Narooma houses as the proxy market. Treat trend metrics as indicative; Kianga's waterside strip has historically run ahead of the blend.
- Confidence is rated Medium-Low overall. The value evidence itself is unusually clean — 20 Kianga Parade (identical 3·2·2, 558 m², same street) sold for $939,000 in March 2026 against the $977,492 AVM — which is exactly why the $1.15M assumption needs premium attributes to justify.
- Five recent nearby sales have undisclosed prices (incl. 16 Kianga Parade next to the comp) — re-check disclosures before an offer; they could move the band.
- Financing figures anchor on an assumed purchase price of $1,150,000 — ~18% above the $977,492 AVM and ~22% above the same-street sale ($939,000). At that price a valuation shortfall is a live risk; a lender valuation decides the real number.
- Coastal / lifestyle markets carry higher amplitude through cycles — strong on the way up, more exposed on the way down — relative to metro benchmarks.
- All AirROI short-stay figures are AUD, pulled direct from the AirROI API on 2 July 2026, and assume a 3bd/2ba/6-guest actively-let, well-presented listing. Kianga skews holiday-house, so blended market averages understate an active operator.
- Short-stay income is typically assessed conservatively (or excluded) by the credit team for serviceability; a signed long-term lease or agent rental appraisal is the stronger evidence for a finance submission.